some 19th century guy with a name like Horatio “Fisticuffs Pete” Thistlecock, probably.
WabbitCZEN
Mike Trout.
Lucky_Alternative965
Konnor Griffin
cubs52
😭😭😭
fxxftw
*Coach Trev*
lifeisarichcarpet
Ernie Banks, Ron Santo or Luke Appling.
Hour_Equipment_2035
Felix Hernandez
Swimming_Elk_3058
All time it is easily Ernie Banks. But he played most of his career when the “postseason” was just the World Series which really limited opportunities.
If you narrow it to guys who played most/all of their career after 1969 when the postseason started to expand into an actual tournament, I would say it’s Fergie Jenkins or Buddy Bell. Felix Hernandez is probably the best from this century to never make it.
BorisDiawisGod
Unrelated, but I just realized Ernie Banks kind of looks like Kobe
RonWill79
Mike Trout is so close to being the obvious choice here. Damn those pesky 3 playoff games.
3dge-1ord
At first glance that looked like Micheal Jordan.
Which would be a good answer if you specified mlb postseason. Yet still left « player » vague.
Kakali4
“King” Félix Hernández comes to mind to me without Google
brybrymma
I don’t recall Felix Hernandez ever playing in the postseason.
Worried-Lettuce6568
Aaron Judge
Leftfeet
Cap Anson.
MalarkeyMcGee
I thought that was Michael Jordan for a sec
J_Dabson002
Fergie
LongjumpingContext95
Paul Skenes
Outside-Skirt
MR Cub!!!!
guystringofnumbers
Cubs honestly do have 3 contenders here with Ernie, Fergie, and Ronny
21 Comments
Zack Britton
some 19th century guy with a name like Horatio “Fisticuffs Pete” Thistlecock, probably.
Mike Trout.
Konnor Griffin
😭😭😭
*Coach Trev*
Ernie Banks, Ron Santo or Luke Appling.
Felix Hernandez
All time it is easily Ernie Banks. But he played most of his career when the “postseason” was just the World Series which really limited opportunities.
If you narrow it to guys who played most/all of their career after 1969 when the postseason started to expand into an actual tournament, I would say it’s Fergie Jenkins or Buddy Bell. Felix Hernandez is probably the best from this century to never make it.
Unrelated, but I just realized Ernie Banks kind of looks like Kobe
Mike Trout is so close to being the obvious choice here. Damn those pesky 3 playoff games.
At first glance that looked like Micheal Jordan.
Which would be a good answer if you specified mlb postseason. Yet still left « player » vague.
“King” Félix Hernández comes to mind to me without Google
I don’t recall Felix Hernandez ever playing in the postseason.
Aaron Judge
Cap Anson.
I thought that was Michael Jordan for a sec
Fergie
Paul Skenes
MR Cub!!!!
Cubs honestly do have 3 contenders here with Ernie, Fergie, and Ronny