I would have said no way a caught steroid user like Tatis gets in, but now that the BBWAA has said cheating doesn’t matter anymore, I think it’s a decent list.
nardling_13
Bryce Harper not even borderline?
MTSORS
Soto will 100% be first ballot
BrandonStRandy1993
Goldschmidt is in. Should be in the tier above
nickthearchaeologist
Uh… Altuve but not Seager? A choice…
phlpdxster
No Phillies…
Superlegend29
Stanton will get in with his 500 hrs
MattDaaaaaaaaamon
Goldschmidt is 100% in
alakakalalal
I’m kinda iffy on Altuve with all of the controversy in 2017. I think that Soto and Freeman will end their careers as a first ballot players. Outside of that this list looks pretty solid to me
Edit: I just realized that Harper isn’t even on this list. He should definitely get in
jgamez76
I might bump Cole up tbh. Especially if Felix gets in. There’s a clear push for « peak over longevity » among voters.
Efficient-Orange-607
Not to include Cal is a travesty. Best catcher in the league. By far.
GreedyRaisin3357
Polar Bear??
Essex626
Soto is younger than some of those « young stars on their way. »
Also, why not Harper, at least on that borderline tier?
babe_ruthless3
Rage bait post.
Senor_frog_85
Add Bregman and Altuve to the list.
National-Belt5893
Do the people who made this list even watch baseball?
victims_sanction
I love clutch but I dont see it sadly
TPain518
Mcutchen, Chapman and Goldy. NO
Jackismyboy
De la Cruz and Pena have quite a ways to go. They’ll have to tighten it up.
21 Comments
[deleted]
I would have said no way a caught steroid user like Tatis gets in, but now that the BBWAA has said cheating doesn’t matter anymore, I think it’s a decent list.
Bryce Harper not even borderline?
Soto will 100% be first ballot
Goldschmidt is in. Should be in the tier above
Uh… Altuve but not Seager? A choice…
No Phillies…
Stanton will get in with his 500 hrs
Goldschmidt is 100% in
I’m kinda iffy on Altuve with all of the controversy in 2017. I think that Soto and Freeman will end their careers as a first ballot players. Outside of that this list looks pretty solid to me
Edit: I just realized that Harper isn’t even on this list. He should definitely get in
I might bump Cole up tbh. Especially if Felix gets in. There’s a clear push for « peak over longevity » among voters.
Not to include Cal is a travesty. Best catcher in the league. By far.
Polar Bear??
Soto is younger than some of those « young stars on their way. »
Also, why not Harper, at least on that borderline tier?
Rage bait post.
Add Bregman and Altuve to the list.
Do the people who made this list even watch baseball?
I love clutch but I dont see it sadly
Mcutchen, Chapman and Goldy. NO
De la Cruz and Pena have quite a ways to go. They’ll have to tighten it up.
No Kershaw?