Is this the worst challenge of the year so far? First pitch of the game and it’s not even close
Will had been pretty decent at challenges (9/14, 9th out of 60 catchers in « overturns vs expected ») up until now, but this was terrible
Routine_Ad_9794
That’s….a choice.
sadclassicrocklover
Even if it was a strike it’s still not worth it to use it so early
Luis_Severino
A lot of teams are probably gonna implement stricter rules for when they’ll challenge. E.g. Top of the first with nobody on means no challenging
Squatchyhiker
Does Ohtani usually touch the back of his hat like that? Hadn’t noticed it before and he did it just before Smith actually challenged it.
Rjptz
what are we doing will come on
Bishop_Cornflake
I’m in the « this system shows how good the umps are » camp. Calling balls and strikes has always struck me a difficult undertaking.
Beer-Me
That was dumb of him
sfan27
Wait that looked like a nice top of zone strike the way he framed it. You’re telling me it was low?!?
I’m not sure which is worse, the framing or the challenge.
jesonnier1
Why challenge the 1st pitch?
Jonjon428
Lmao why
No-Check4283
and he tryed to frame up to the very top of the zone.
ImmediateMidnight583
Cant argue with how good they are, and the rings show that but man it felt good seeing will smoth tap his head only to sit there and look like a complete a idiot lol
Whyra
Dodgers out here doing challenge runs at this point
Can you win an MLB game in 2026 with ZERO challenges??!
Batters are talking a lot of shit rest of the game to the catcher right?
AdamantArmadillo
He was going for the elusive « perfect ABS game » (challenge every single pitch and prove the ump was wrong on every pitch). Ah well, try again tomorrow
kookykrazee
From what I have seen and heard from announces catchers, pitchers and hitters all seem to not have a grasp on the lower ball calls.
Powerful_Lime_1430
Very low IQ challenge
ForsakenRacism
ABS is sos stupid. The umps are fine
9001
That’s not Will Smith. That’s just some cracker.
SuspiciousYard2484

ace51689
I can’t wait to see at the end of the year which catchers have the best and worst challenge percentage.
Jaximaus
I think I saw someone say that Will Smith probably saw Ohtani adjusting his hat and mistakenly thought he was requesting a challenge. Will was probably just making sure the request was granted.
htownchuck
They did this on purpose. The challenges make the game to easy for them.
Greenpeppers23
Of course the Dodgers had to also steal “worst challenge ever” award
starkvonhammer
When your framing fools yourself.
vladfan27
Best thing about the ABS is if a hitter or pitcher tries to show up the ump by disagreeing with their call, the ump can just be like « then why don’t you challenge it »
30 Comments
Is this the worst challenge of the year so far? First pitch of the game and it’s not even close
Will had been pretty decent at challenges (9/14, 9th out of 60 catchers in « overturns vs expected ») up until now, but this was terrible
That’s….a choice.
Even if it was a strike it’s still not worth it to use it so early
A lot of teams are probably gonna implement stricter rules for when they’ll challenge. E.g. Top of the first with nobody on means no challenging
Does Ohtani usually touch the back of his hat like that? Hadn’t noticed it before and he did it just before Smith actually challenged it.
what are we doing will come on
I’m in the « this system shows how good the umps are » camp. Calling balls and strikes has always struck me a difficult undertaking.
That was dumb of him
Wait that looked like a nice top of zone strike the way he framed it. You’re telling me it was low?!?
I’m not sure which is worse, the framing or the challenge.
Why challenge the 1st pitch?
Lmao why
and he tryed to frame up to the very top of the zone.
Cant argue with how good they are, and the rings show that but man it felt good seeing will smoth tap his head only to sit there and look like a complete a idiot lol
Dodgers out here doing challenge runs at this point
Can you win an MLB game in 2026 with ZERO challenges??!
[Just trying to…](https://tenor.com/view/shoresy-set-the-tone-gif-7740488259383726561)
Stupid
Wow dude close one!
Batters are talking a lot of shit rest of the game to the catcher right?
He was going for the elusive « perfect ABS game » (challenge every single pitch and prove the ump was wrong on every pitch). Ah well, try again tomorrow
From what I have seen and heard from announces catchers, pitchers and hitters all seem to not have a grasp on the lower ball calls.
Very low IQ challenge
ABS is sos stupid. The umps are fine
That’s not Will Smith. That’s just some cracker.

I can’t wait to see at the end of the year which catchers have the best and worst challenge percentage.
I think I saw someone say that Will Smith probably saw Ohtani adjusting his hat and mistakenly thought he was requesting a challenge. Will was probably just making sure the request was granted.
They did this on purpose. The challenges make the game to easy for them.
Of course the Dodgers had to also steal “worst challenge ever” award
When your framing fools yourself.
Best thing about the ABS is if a hitter or pitcher tries to show up the ump by disagreeing with their call, the ump can just be like « then why don’t you challenge it »