Ohtani is an amazing player but Judge is the best hitter in the league by far. Probably best since old Barry himself.
Gigi_0102
Ohtani is a better overall player but Judge is the better hitter.
cmgriffith_
Aaron Judge is the better hitter
darkravenn12
The meme Ohtani glaze continues
--Rick--Astley--
They know Ohtani is more popular so they ranked him number one. It’s so blatant.
helpslipnofranklins
Somehow I am unbothered by having Kurtz and Caminero tied at 10. Feels like a good spot for both of them
dirtywater29
Rule 3
bobobobobobobobobo3
Classic mlb.com rage bait
Life_Database_7038
Juan Soto is the Drew Brees of baseball.
LargeNutbar
Judge’s 2025 league-best OPS was .130 better than second-best Ohtani’s, that’s the same gap as between Soto and 62nd place Ryan Mountcastle
AlpsGroundbreaking67
Only qualm is Bobby at 8 instead of 5
Zeke-Nnjai
What could possibly be the argument for Shohei over Judge?
MaskedBandit77
No Konner Griffin? /s
[deleted]
[deleted]
jonpictogramjones
Pure hitting judge is better than
Brundleflyftw
Raleigh seems a bit high.
CanadianSyrup1994
Wait, if this is a pure hitter top 10, where is Volpe?
Muted-Capital-4954
“This wedding is horse shit”
WiseIndustry2895
Presented by oxi clean
UniqueEditor8372
Judge just makes it look too effortless. Last year his stats made Cal look like a replacement level player by comparison but you wouldn’t know it from the discourse. Meanwhile every time Ohtani shits it’s a headline about what a generational deuce it was.
TonyTwoGs
Give me a minute the delivery guys is leaving
Panguin9
No one wants to say it but by far the worst ranking here is Witt. For a shortstop he’s incredible but purely in terms of hitting he’s nowhere close to top 10
SLR107FR-31
No
MiEzRo
I must be in too deep with planning my sons 8th birthday party because I read this as “the first Harry Potter rankings of 2026” 🤣
Da_Taternater78
There is zero argument for Ohtani over Judge
RIP_Greedo
The glazings will continue until morale improves.
MakaveliX1996
Whoever made this just took the #1 spot for being a fucking idiot.
37 Comments
Ah, engagement bait.
I love Ohtani but anybody ranking him above Judge in pure hitting is trolling.
I love Ohtani but Judge is definitely the better pure hitter.
This has got to be engagement bait right?
Judge won’t be appreciated like he should be until folks look back at his baseball reference years after he retires
Any list that claims Judge isn’t the best hitter in the game can be ignored.
If we are doing all around player, ok we can debate things. But he puts up video game numbers every year.
I read this as Hitler power rankings for a second lmao
I will be incredibly surprised if Raleigh doesn’t regress
Better hitter, Judge. Better overall player, Ohtani.
Ohtani is an amazing player but Judge is the best hitter in the league by far. Probably best since old Barry himself.
Ohtani is a better overall player but Judge is the better hitter.
Aaron Judge is the better hitter
The meme Ohtani glaze continues
They know Ohtani is more popular so they ranked him number one. It’s so blatant.
Somehow I am unbothered by having Kurtz and Caminero tied at 10. Feels like a good spot for both of them
Rule 3
Classic mlb.com rage bait
Juan Soto is the Drew Brees of baseball.
Judge’s 2025 league-best OPS was .130 better than second-best Ohtani’s, that’s the same gap as between Soto and 62nd place Ryan Mountcastle
Only qualm is Bobby at 8 instead of 5
What could possibly be the argument for Shohei over Judge?
No Konner Griffin? /s
[deleted]
Pure hitting judge is better than
Raleigh seems a bit high.
Wait, if this is a pure hitter top 10, where is Volpe?
“This wedding is horse shit”
Presented by oxi clean
Judge just makes it look too effortless. Last year his stats made Cal look like a replacement level player by comparison but you wouldn’t know it from the discourse. Meanwhile every time Ohtani shits it’s a headline about what a generational deuce it was.
Give me a minute the delivery guys is leaving
No one wants to say it but by far the worst ranking here is Witt. For a shortstop he’s incredible but purely in terms of hitting he’s nowhere close to top 10
No
I must be in too deep with planning my sons 8th birthday party because I read this as “the first Harry Potter rankings of 2026” 🤣
There is zero argument for Ohtani over Judge
The glazings will continue until morale improves.
Whoever made this just took the #1 spot for being a fucking idiot.
Yordan?
Bait