I’ll never understand comparison charts with counting stats that don’t include ABs. Manny has ~1500 more than JRam
Joey_Gallos_Burner
Oops, all HoFers.
WurmcoilEngine11
Taking JRam every day. Dude practically lives in scoring position
HuckleberryAny4541
I still remember when J-Ram was about to be traded away because the Guardians didn’t want to pay him properly and J-Ram still blocked the trade and stayed in Cleveland.
I think the Mets were one of the teams that wanted to trade for J-Ram, what a great trade that would have been 🤑🤑🤑🤑, sadly J-Ram loves Cleveland too much
Diced_and_Confused
If you had to pick only one of these players for your team, who would you want? I’d want Jose every day.
Broad-Cranberry-9050
I was always more of an arenado guy but i do feel like history will remember machado as better down the road.
Maybe im wrong, but id give arenado the slight edge as a player (it’s close though).
But machado played for more historic franchises, was kind of the leader and the first ball to roll for the modern day san diego padres and has been the leader of that and that rivalry with the dodgers has made them relevant.
Arenado went from a rockies with no attention, to cardinals had some success but i dont think most will remember him for his time there and just went to arizona.
Routine_Ad_9794
JRam inspires the most fear for me. Dude’s a certified Yankee killer.
and-you-know-it
All HOFers. Great crop of 3rd basemen.
bigtimeNS
Give me JRam all damn day.
CoolCryptoCat
Personally don’t think Arenado is a HoFer unless he tacks on a significant more WAR. But helluva player and insane defense.
Hate Machado, but I think he’s easily headed to the HoF. Just smells like a guy who will be adding all the requisite numbers till the age of 40. Loved by none, but acknowledged by all.
JoRam is goated. Just 2 more “typical” JoRam yrs and I think he’s a shoe-in. Hell, his numbers probably gets in via Veterans down the road if he suddenly retired today.
Just my 2 cents, ty for coming to my Ted Talk.
NeighborhoodBusy4314
Manny does it again
scottborasismyagent
where is hollywood lifestyle ?

broadwhim
crazy nolan’s stats are still that good despite his last few years
COV3RTSM
One is a great ball player but a giant dickhead, one is a great ball player, the heart and soul of a franchise in city that he’s endeared himself to, the other is Nolan Arenado.
brandochu009
Ramirez = 🥇
regal19999
Jose has the best glove of the 3 imo
itbethatway_
Manny and Arenado are fun comparisons. Very similar player with Manny having the offense edge while Arenado is one of the greatest fielders.
JRam is in a different category. He isn’t an elite fielder like the other two. But he is a beautiful blend of speed, contact, and power.
forpornonly1234567
still would much rather have Nolen Arenado than Manny Machado
18 Comments
I’ll never understand comparison charts with counting stats that don’t include ABs. Manny has ~1500 more than JRam
Oops, all HoFers.
Taking JRam every day. Dude practically lives in scoring position
I still remember when J-Ram was about to be traded away because the Guardians didn’t want to pay him properly and J-Ram still blocked the trade and stayed in Cleveland.
I think the Mets were one of the teams that wanted to trade for J-Ram, what a great trade that would have been 🤑🤑🤑🤑, sadly J-Ram loves Cleveland too much
If you had to pick only one of these players for your team, who would you want? I’d want Jose every day.
I was always more of an arenado guy but i do feel like history will remember machado as better down the road.
Maybe im wrong, but id give arenado the slight edge as a player (it’s close though).
But machado played for more historic franchises, was kind of the leader and the first ball to roll for the modern day san diego padres and has been the leader of that and that rivalry with the dodgers has made them relevant.
Arenado went from a rockies with no attention, to cardinals had some success but i dont think most will remember him for his time there and just went to arizona.
JRam inspires the most fear for me. Dude’s a certified Yankee killer.
All HOFers. Great crop of 3rd basemen.
Give me JRam all damn day.
Personally don’t think Arenado is a HoFer unless he tacks on a significant more WAR. But helluva player and insane defense.
Hate Machado, but I think he’s easily headed to the HoF. Just smells like a guy who will be adding all the requisite numbers till the age of 40. Loved by none, but acknowledged by all.
JoRam is goated. Just 2 more “typical” JoRam yrs and I think he’s a shoe-in. Hell, his numbers probably gets in via Veterans down the road if he suddenly retired today.
Just my 2 cents, ty for coming to my Ted Talk.
Manny does it again
where is hollywood lifestyle ?

crazy nolan’s stats are still that good despite his last few years
One is a great ball player but a giant dickhead, one is a great ball player, the heart and soul of a franchise in city that he’s endeared himself to, the other is Nolan Arenado.
Ramirez = 🥇
Jose has the best glove of the 3 imo
Manny and Arenado are fun comparisons. Very similar player with Manny having the offense edge while Arenado is one of the greatest fielders.
JRam is in a different category. He isn’t an elite fielder like the other two. But he is a beautiful blend of speed, contact, and power.
still would much rather have Nolen Arenado than Manny Machado